The Gateway Academy Basketball Team winning a high school basketball game.

The islands of Bimini not only have superior activities on the water, but also offer exclusive traditional sports on the ground. Private Cat Cay Island offers its members golf at Windsor Downs, a course named for the Duke of Windsor who was a former Governor in The Bahamas and a frequent guest on the island. Cat Cay also offers members tennis on two lighted tennis courts next to the golf course. Other tennis courts can be found at Bimini Sands Resort & Marina on South Bimini and at Resorts World Bimini on North Bimini for the use of guests. Complimentary balls and rackets are available. Several competitive walkathons and fun races are organized by civic organizations and community groups throughout the year and visitors can join in. Swimming as a sport can be practiced in Cat Cay’s heated Olympic-sized pool or across a secluded protected bay on the island.

Bimini has also produced some of the best athletes in The Bahamas. Baseball has been one of the most passionate sports played here for many years, leading to a few young men from the island pursuing it as a career. One of their stars is Jervis 'Champ' Stuart (pictured on the right), who went on to play professional baseball.